top of page

Live-in Care vs. Care Homes

Live-in Carer arriving on doorstep of client's house

In this helpful guide, we'll explore the two best known types of elder care support - Residential Care Homes and Live-in Care. We’ll show you why we think live-in care could be the perfect fit for you or your elderly loved one. 

Written for you by our team of experts here at Access Care, after 30 years in the Live-in care industry, we understand how overwhelming the decision on long-term care can be, especially with so many options that are now available. 

While residential care homes have traditionally been a popular choice for elderly support and for those with Dementia, there's now a growing trend towards more personal and independent care options like live-in care.

The Landscape of Elderly Care

When people are looking at long-term care for themselves or their loved ones, they often weigh the pros and cons of two primary care solutions: live-in care and care homes. But what are these options, and what do they entail?

What is Live-in Care?

Live-in care is quite a modern approach to care support that means people are able to stay in the comfort of their own homes while also receiving the necessary level of support. 

This option involves a live-in carer living in the home with the client requiring care, providing a personalised and attentive level of service that can adapt to the evolving needs of the individual. 

The home carer can get involved with lots of different things including; 

  • assisting with daily activities

  • personal care routines and medicine 

  • providing companionship

  • handling household tasks

Live-in carers offer a comprehensive solution that emphasises independence and personal dignity.

Understanding Care Homes

Care homes, often referred to as nursing homes or residential care facilities, represent a more traditional approach to elderly care. 

These purpose built establishments provide a communal living environment where individuals have access to round-the-clock support and medical care. 

Unlike live-in care, which emphasises personalisation and individual attention, care homes are structured to cater to the needs of multiple residents simultaneously. 

Facilities typically offer private or shared rooms, communal dining areas, and a schedule of activities designed to encourage social interaction. 

While this option ensures safety and constant access to care, it may present challenges for those who value their privacy and autonomy, making it a critical consideration for families and individuals making long-term care decisions.

A Comparison at a Glance

When choosing between live-in care and care homes, it’s essential to consider several key factors:

Cost of Care

One of the most significant considerations for many families is the cost of care. Initially, live-in care might seem like a more expensive option compared to care homes. However, it's essential to consider the value of the personalised attention and the fact that expenses for living at home are already covered in your usual costs. 

In comparison, care homes charge for accommodation and care, which can quickly add up, especially for higher levels of medical or personal support as conditions progress. 

Live-in care allows for a direct relationship with the home carer, which means that personalised care can be more flexible and adapted to the changing needs of the client without additional costs for every small adjustment. 

On the other hand, care homes have set fees that increase with the level and complexity of care required, and these increments can be significant and not always transparent upfront.

In-depth analysis often reveals that live-in care can be a cost-effective solution when taking into account the quality of life, personal attention, and comfort of staying in one's own home. 

It's also worth noting that some insurance policies and care funding options may cover or contribute to the cost of live-in care, further mitigating the financial burden on families.

Level of Support

The level of support offered is another critical factor when comparing live-in care and care homes. 

With live-in care, the assistance is highly personalised and can be adjusted to meet the evolving health conditions and preferences of the client. 

This means everything from the type of care to the daily routine can be tailored specifically to the individual, ensuring they feel comfortable and respected in their own home. 

This personalisation extends to social activities, with home carers often facilitating engagement in hobbies, local community events, or maintaining social connections that would be more challenging in a care home setting.

Residential Care Homes provide a more standardised level of care that, while professional, may not offer the same degree of personal attention or flexibility. 

The social environment in care homes can be vibrant, offering opportunities for interaction with other residents, but may also pose challenges for those who value their privacy or prefer a quieter, more individual lifestyle. 

Understanding the level of support required and the preferred living environment is vital in making an informed decision between live-in care and a care home arrangement.

Daily Routine and Personal Freedom

Maintaining a sense of normalcy and control over one's daily life is crucial for the well-being of elderly people considering long-term care. 

Live-in care naturally offers a higher degree of control over daily routines and personal freedom compared to care homes. Clients receiving live-in care continue living in their own homes, which means they can dictate their meal times, social activities, and sleeping schedules. 

This level of personal autonomy is particularly beneficial for maintaining mental health and a sense of independence, which can significantly impact overall happiness and satisfaction.

In contrast, care homes operate on a fixed schedule to manage the care of multiple residents efficiently. This means that individuals may have less flexibility regarding when they eat, participate in activities, or go to bed. 

While good care homes strive to accommodate personal preferences, the communal living setup inherently requires some level of compromise on individual routines and freedoms.

The choice between live-in care and care homes must, therefore, consider how important daily routine and personal autonomy are to the individual requiring care. 

For many, the ability to maintain their lifestyle and independence in the comfort of their own home is a deciding factor in opting for live-in care.

Privacy and Comfort

Privacy and comfort are paramount factors when considering long-term care options. Live-in care uniquely offers a level of privacy that cannot be matched by care homes, as individuals remain in the comfort and familiarity of their own houses. 

This environment allows for a personalised living space that reflects the individual's tastes, with personal belongings and memories that promote a sense of well-being and identity.  

As well as that, being in your own home provides a sanctuary where privacy is respected, memories are all around and personal space is guaranteed.

In comparison, while care homes attempt to create a homely environment, the nature of communal living means that privacy and space can sometimes be compromised. 

Residents often have private rooms, but shared dining areas, lounges, and other communal facilities mean that finding personal space can be challenging. 

For those who have lived independently for most of their lives, adjusting to these communal spaces can be a significant shift.

The comfort provided by living in a familiar environment also significantly impacts an individual's quality of life. The ability to sleep in one’s own bed, use personal items, and even interact with pets contributes to a sense of normalcy and contentment. 

Live-in care supports this level of comfort by adapting the care provided to the environment, rather than requiring the individual to adapt to a new setting, as is the case with care homes.

Considering the importance of privacy and comfort, especially with advancing age, the decision between live-in care and care homes should weigh these aspects carefully. 

The right choice varies from one individual to another, depending on their values, condition, and the level of care they require.

Long-Term Relationships and Emotional Health

An often-overlooked advantage of live-in care is the potential for building long-term, meaningful relationships and companionship between the home carer and the client. 

Such relationships can have a profound impact on the emotional and psychological well-being of the person receiving care. The consistent presence of a live-in carer allows for a deeper understanding and connection, leading to a more compassionate and empathetic form of care that extends beyond mere physical needs. 

This can alleviate feelings of loneliness and depression, which are common concerns among the elderly.

Care homes, while fostering a community environment, might not always offer the same depth of personal connection due to the larger number of residents and the varying staff members who attend to individuals' needs. 

Though friendships among residents can form, the one-on-one interaction with carers is less frequent, which can affect the quality of emotional support provided.

The impact of emotional health on the overall quality of life cannot be understated. Feelings of belonging, being understood, and cared for are crucial, making the choice of live-in care even more appealing for those who prioritise personal connections and emotional support in their care requirements.

The Benefits of Live-in Care

Choosing live-in care can provide a wealth of benefits, from personalised care to maintaining a familiar way of life. It’s a service that has been found to be particularly beneficial for individuals with conditions like dementia, helping them retain a sense of self in their homes.

Personalised Care Support

Personalised care support is the hallmark of live-in care, allowing the service to be tailored specifically to the individual's needs, preferences, and routines. 

Unlike a residential care home setting where care support and schedules must be adapted to fit an institutional routine, live-in carers can focus entirely on the client, adjusting schedules, activities, and healthcare interventions to suit their home care client’s life. 

This bespoke and private approach not only ensures that physical health is managed effectively but also supports the emotional and psychological well-being of the client, reinforcing the value of respect and dignity in care. 

The flexibility of live-in care to adapt to changing needs over time further underscores its effectiveness as a long-term care solution, providing peace of mind for both the individual in care and their family.


Beyond the practicalities of daily assistance and healthcare management, the companionship that live-in care offers is invaluable. This form of care ensures that individuals are not only looked after but also have someone to share their day and experiences with, which is essential for mental and emotional well-being. 

Companion care can transform the care experience, turning it into an opportunity for social interaction, friendship, and shared enjoyment of life. For many, this aspect of live-in care significantly reduces the risk of social isolation and loneliness, which are critical issues for the elderly population. 

The presence of a home carer who is attuned to their client’s hobbies, interests, and stories adds a layer of personal fulfilment that goes far beyond basic care needs, enhancing the individual's quality of life each day.

Flexibility in Daily Living

One of the greatest benefits of live-in care is the flexibility it provides in daily living. Unlike in a care home, where schedules for meals, activities, and bedtime are set for all residents, live-in care adapts to the personal habits and preferences of the individual. 

This means that individuals can eat their meals when they want, go out for activities as they choose, and maintain their lifelong routines without disruption. 

This level of autonomy and self-determination is not only important for the individual’s sense of independence but also crucial for their mental health and overall happiness. 

The ability to continue living life according to one's own schedule and preferences promotes a sense of normalcy and control, which can be particularly empowering for those dealing with the vulnerabilities that come with age or illness.

Enhanced Safety and Security

For the elderly, particularly those with mobility issues or conditions like dementia, safety at home is a paramount concern. Live-in care significantly enhances personal safety by ensuring that help is always at hand, reducing the risk of falls and providing immediate response in case of an emergency. 

This constant presence offers peace of mind not only to the client but also to their family members, knowing that their loved one is in safe hands.

Continuity of Care

Another advantage of live-in care is the continuity it offers. Clients typically have one or two primary home carers, allowing for a strong, trusting relationship to develop. 

This continuity of care can be particularly comforting for those with progressive conditions, as the live-in carer is familiar with their history, preferences, and needs. 

By contrast, in care homes, staffing shifts can lead to a more varied range of carers interacting with clients, which might be stressful for some.

Keeping Pets

Pets are often considered part of the family, offering companionship and comfort, particularly to the elderly. 

Most care homes do not allow pets, which can be a heartbreaking situation for many. 

Live-in care solves this problem by allowing clients to keep their pets with them. The emotional and physical benefits of this continuity can be profound, including lower stress levels and increased physical activity.

How to Make the Right Choice

When determining the best care solution, there are a few steps you can take to ensure your decision aligns with your needs and those of your loved ones.

The first step in making the right choice for care involves thoroughly assessing the health needs of the person requiring support. 

This encompasses understanding both the physical and mental health challenges they face. Identifying the level of care needed—whether it's assistance with daily tasks, specialised support for conditions like dementia, or 24/7 supervision—can help determine if live-in care is the most suitable option. 

Consulting with healthcare professionals to gain insights into the individual's medical requirements can also provide invaluable guidance during this decision-making process. Recognising the nature and extent of care needed is crucial for selecting a service that not only addresses current health issues but also adapts to future needs as they evolve.

Considering the lifestyle of the person in need of care is essential to ensuring their happiness and satisfaction with the chosen care arrangement. 

This includes taking into account their social habits, hobbies, and overall preferences for daily activities. For someone who enjoys a quiet, private life, the one-on-one interaction of live-in care might be preferable. 

Conversely, individuals who thrive in social settings might benefit from the structured community activities offered in a care home setting. It's also important to think about the level of independence desired; live-in care often allows for a greater sense of freedom, as it can be more easily tailored to fit personal schedules and lifestyles. Reflecting on these aspects helps in choosing a care solution that not only meets health needs but also aligns with personal values and life enjoyment.

Your habits, hobbies, and living standards play a significant role in your choice. If you're keen on maintaining a lot of your independence and customs, live-in care is likely the better fit.

Financial considerations are crucial when selecting the most appropriate care option. Both Live-in care and Care Homes are significant in cost, but can also differ greatly - impacted by factors such as the level of care required, location, and any additional services needed. 

Live-in care, while offering the benefit of personalised, one-on-one attention, might be more cost-effective for those requiring round-the-clock assistance compared to the cumulative costs of a care home. 

It's essential to do a thorough analysis of all expenses, including hidden costs and potential financial assistance available through insurance or governmental support programs. 

Understanding the full financial implications of each care option can help in making a decision that is not only beneficial for the recipient’s well-being but also sustainable for their financial situation.

Finances undoubtedly influence your options. Understand the costs associated with each type of care and what services are included in the quoted amount.

Access Care – Choosing a Trusted Live-In Provider

In the field of live-in care, we believe that Access Care stands out for providing tailored care solutions. Our approach is centred on compassion, professionalism, and a thorough understanding of each of our client’s specific needs.

Testimonials from Our Clients and Live-In Carers

One of the defining characteristics that set Access Care apart from others in the field is the rigour and care invested in matching home carers with clients. 

Our detailed matching process considers not just the care needs but also personality traits, hobbies, interests, and lifestyle preferences. 

This personalised approach ensures that clients do not just receive the care they need but are also paired with a live-in carer with whom they can build a meaningful, lasting relationship.

Hearing directly from those we've supported offers the best insight into the difference Access Care can make. 

For instance, John, a client's son, shares, 

"The care my mother received from her live-in carer was outstanding. Not only were her medical needs meticulously looked after, but the compassionate companionship and shared laughter made her final years her best ones." 

Such testimonials highlight the impact that thoughtful, personalised care can have on both clients and their families, providing not just assistance, but also enhancing the quality of life.

The Live-in Care Vs Residential Care: The On-Going Debate

Choosing the right care for your later years is crucial, and while both live-in care and care homes have their place, there's a reason why more and more elderly people are choosing to stay in the comfort of their homes with live-in care support.

As a local live-in care agency experienced in providing live-in carers for individuals who require specialised support. - here at Access Care we recognise that every person’s journey is unique.  

Our care options are tailored to meet the specific needs and preferences of each live-in care client. Whether it's assisting with exercises, accompanying to medical appointments, or simply providing a listening ear, our live-in carers are dedicated to promoting the physical, emotional, and mental well-being of those in our care. 

With 24 hour live in care from our compassionate live-in carers, you can have peace of mind knowing that your loved one is in capable and caring hands. 

If you have a relative or loved one who could benefit from the support of a live-in carer, please don't hesitate to reach out to us. You can call us on 01264 319399 or email to learn more about how we can assist you. 

As a home care client of ours, you can trust that one of our home carers will provide you 24 hour live in care tailored to meet your individual needs. Let us be your partner in care, supporting you every step of the way.


bottom of page