top of page

Navigating Care Options in the UK: A Comparative Analysis of Live-in Care, Hourly Care & Care Homes


According to the ONS (Office for national statistics), Care home residents of both genders had a lower life expectancy across all age groups compared with non-care home residents in the same age groups.

As the population ages, the demand for care services in the UK has grown exponentially, prompting a diverse array of options for families and individuals seeking the best possible care for their loved ones. Among these options, three primary choices stand out: 24 hour live-in home care, domiciliary hourly care, and residential care homes. Each of these choices has its own advantages and disadvantages, catering to different preferences, needs, and circumstances. In this article, we will delve into the intricacies of these care options, comparing and contrasting their features and service levels to help families across the UK make informed decisions for their aging relatives.

 Smiling elderly Live In Care clients outside holding hands

Key Questions to Consider

When evaluating the suitability of live-in elderly care, hourly homecare, and residential care homes, several essential questions come to mind:

1. What Level of Care is Required?

Does the person require constant, round-the-clock care due to medical conditions or cognitive impairments?

Is the person relatively independent and only requires assistance with certain activities?

2. Preference for Familiar Surroundings:

Does the person wish to remain in the comfort of their own home?

Are they open to relocating to a new environment or location?

3. Social Interaction:

Does the person value social interactions and community engagement?

Would they benefit from being in close proximity to old friends and family?

4. Cost Considerations:

What is the budget available for care, how will it be funded?

How do the costs of live-in care, domiciliary hourly care, and residential care homes compare?

5. Medical and Safety Requirements:

Are there specific medical needs that require specialised care?

Is the home environment safe and conducive to aging in place?

6. Flexibility and Customisation:

Does the persons’ routine require a flexible caregiving schedule?

Is there a need for tailored care plans that can evolve as needs change?

7. Burden on Family Caregivers:

To what extent can family members be involved in caregiving?

What level of support is available from family members?

Comparative Analysis

Live-in Care: Elder live in care provides the opportunity to remain living in the comfort and familiarity of their own home. A dedicated home carer resides in the house, offering personalised attention and support around the clock 24/7. This option is particularly suitable for those who value familiarity, wish to maintain a sense of independence, and would benefit from constant monitoring due to medical or cognitive conditions. While offering a high degree of customisation and companionship, it can be more costly than hourly care but becomes a less-expensive option once 3-4hrs of care calls per day are reached and is comparable and sometimes less expensive than residential care homes, especially if a couple are needing care together. One qualified home carer is typically able to care for an elderly couple providing high quality home help for the elderly.

Hourly Care: Hourly care involves domiciliary caregivers visiting the home at specified times to provide personal care assistance with various activities, such as meal preparation, medication reminders, bathing, and companionship. This option is more rigid in that a home carer is working to a tight schedule so the care calls will be a specific time of the day and often provided by different caregivers on each day, despite the best efforts of the homecare agency. A domiciliary care agency is an ideal for those who need minimal assistance and desire to remain in their homes. However, it might not be sufficient for individuals with more complex care needs and often cover will be provided by a team which may lack continuity and be confusing.

Residential Care Homes: Residential care homes provide a community-oriented environment offering round-the-clock care, social interactions, and a range of activities. These homes are best suited to those who are open to living in a communal setting and require a higher level of care, including medical attention and assistance with daily activities. While fostering social engagement, residential care homes might lack the personalised touch and close attention of live-in care.


Selecting the right care option requires careful consideration of individual needs, preferences, and financial capabilities. Live in care, hourly care, and residential care homes each have distinct advantages that cater to different situations. By addressing key questions and conducting thorough research, families can make informed decisions that prioritise the well-being and quality of life for their aging loved ones. Ultimately, the goal is to provide the best possible care in an environment that will maintain or improve a person’s quality of life. For more detailed information and advice we the team at Access Care is able to advise and answer all your questions.


bottom of page